analyst
Kevin Jonathan Panjaitan
The world of telecommunications Indonesia is again shaken by the news that XL Axiata (EXCL IJ) and Smartfren (Fren IJ) have officially joined a strategic merger, with the new name XLSmart. With EXCL as the successor entity, this merger promises various opportunities, but cannot be separated from the big challenges that need to be observed.
Why is this important?
This step is not just a merger of two companies, but a strategic step to improve the scale of operations, expand market segments, and increase efficiency. EXCL will manage more than 94.5 million subscribers, including 35.9 million from FREN, and leverage the combined spectrum of 152 MHz (33.6% of the total national). With the focus of different market segments—upper class for XL and the younger generation for Smartfren—XLSmart has the opportunity to serve more customer needs holistically.
Prospects and valuations after the merger
- Valuation: The EXCL combined entity valuation reaches IDR 2,350/share, with an indication of equity value of IDR 42.6 trillion (EV/EBITDA 4.6x), while Fren is at IDR25/share with an indication of equity value of IDR11.9 trillion (EV/EBITDA 5.7x).
- Ownership arrangement: post-merger, the ownership structure will change with Axiata and Sinarmas holding 34.8%, and the public at 30.4%.
- Dividend: EXCL has also promised dividends of IDR1.1 trillion (IDR85/share) in the first half of 2025, with a yield of around 3.8%.
- Potential synergy: This merger is estimated to generate annual efficiency of USD300-400 million in 3-5 years through network optimization, vendors, and digitization.
Reflecting on ISAT-TRI, what about EXCL?
Looking at the experience of the ISAT-TRI merger in 2022, there is a potential for significant efficiency improvement. ISAT EBITDA Margin increased from 40.3% (1Q22) to 47% (4Q23), while net profit jumped 76% in 2022 and 144% in 2023. However, the implementation challenge remains a real risk.
Risks to be taken into account
While the long-term potential is promising, there are some risks to watch out for!
- Intense competition in the telecommunications industry
- Ineffective merger implementation, the dilution impact of net profit due to FREN net loss,
- Potential decline in revenue of tower companies such as TBIG and TOWR due to overlapping sites
So what do we think?
With the target price of EV/EBITDA 5X based on IDR2,770 for EXCL, we remain optimistic about the long-term potential of this merger. Despite the challenges, the resulting synergy has a great opportunity to bring XLSMART to a new level in the Indonesian telecommunications industry. This action provides opportunities for investors who are looking for long-term growth.
Full pdf: bsexcl1224
Disclaimer on:
Buying and selling decisions are personal responsibility
Regards
Investment Specialist
